+27 21 448 4105

Wine Advocate reviews South Africa

Neal Martin succeeded Robert Parker of the Wine Advocate in 2016, becoming the lead taster for Bordeaux, Burgundy and South Africa. Martin’s focus on the world’s top 2 wine regions under the Parker umbrella makes him arguably the most important critic in the world. His cool demeanour, articulate tasting notes and consistency are highly revered by his peers and the wine community alike. The Wine Advocate released the South African and Bordeaux 2016 reports on Friday.

Neil Martin SA report

Martin doesn’t give out points lightly and a 90+ rating indicates a world class wine. Apart from the handful of ‘near-perfect’ wines above 95 points, Martin says, ‘the word that would then pop up in my head wasbargain…There are a dozen wines in this report that vis-à-vis similar wines in other countries could easily double their prices overnight with total justification.’  

Martin went on to say how he was again impressed by the quality of the white wines saying that the ‘top Chenin Blancs are world-beaters’!

We list all the 95+ wines, select 94s that are still available, as well as 92s and 93s that offer amazing value.

To place you order, copy the table, complete it and send it to Nilo@winecellar.co.za.

OR: Order Here 

Producer, Wine and Vintage WA Score Price/bottle Order
Mullineux, Olerasay 375ml NV  99 S/O  
Mullineux, Essence 250ml 2012  98 N/A  
Sadie Family, 'T Voetpad 2015  97 S/O  
Mullineux, Straw Wine 375ml 2016  97 R395  
Sadie Family, Treinspoor 2015  96 R300  
Klein Constantia, Vin de Constance 500ml 2013  96 R895  
Sadie Family, Columella 2014  96 S/O  
Porseleinberg, Syrah 2014  96 S/O  
Ken Forrester, FMC Single Barrel 2014  95 R700  
Sadie Family, Kokerboom 2015  95 S/O  
Keermont, Fleurfontein 375ml 2015  94 R195  
De Morgenzon, Reserve Chardonnay 2016  94 R390  
Keermont, Steepside Syrah 2014  94 R405  
Ken Forrester, FMC Chenin Blanc 2015 94  94 R475  
Vilafonté, Series C 2014  94 R750  
Mullineux, Schist Syrah 2014  94 R905  
Mvemve Raats, De Compostella 2014  94 R1050  
Kanonkop, Black Label Pinotage 2015  94 R1590  
Reyneke, Biodynamic Syrah 2015  93 R160  
Reyneke, Biodynamic Chenin Blanc 2015  93 R180  
Tokara, Reserve Stellenbosch Chardonnay 2015  93 R195  
De Morgenzon, Maestro White 2015  93 R220  
Ataraxia, Chardonnay 2015  93 R245  
Eagles' Nest, Shiraz 2013  93 R295  
Bryan MacRobert Wines, Abbotsdale Shiraz 2015  92 R90  
Alheit, Flotsam & Jetsam Chenin Blanc 2016  92 R130  
Longridge, Pinotage 2015  92 R145  
Tamboerskloof, Syrah 2013  92 R185  
Raats, Red Jasper 2015  92 R190  
Sijnn, White 2015  92 R220  
Wine Cellar offers the greatest wine region in the world en-primeur (as futures). 2016 will be our 16th Bordeaux campaign and will be offered from April 2017 onwards for delivery in 2019.
We update our blog daily with the latest news, videos, tasting reports, recipes and more. It's also a great place to learn about fine wine.
Wine cellar imports fine wine from Europe, offers antipodean wines, fine local wines as well as brokers your fine wine. We also focus on selling wines en-primeur (as futures) from Bordeaux, Burgundy and the Rhône.
We offer tastings in Johannesburg and Cape Town; from comparative tastings for private and corporate groups to tastings of our latest imports for the public. We also offer luxury dinners paired with rare wines.
Professional cellaring of single bottles for private clients through to pallet loads for trade clients. Wines are stored at 14 degrees in our secure underground cellars in Observatory, Cape Town.
Become a Wine Cellar newsletter subscriber and be the first to hear about our latest deals and discoveries. Newsletters are sent weekly/fortnightly.

Advanced Region Filter

All prices include VAT.